22 to 29%overstatement of GDP and jobs from induced effects alone
$5.8bnlifetime GDP from a 1 GW offshore wind farm, against $5.4bn claimed for the mine
20 yearsof proposed extraction reviewed
The question
Trans-Tasman Resources sought approval under the Fast-track Approvals Act to extract 50 million tonnes of seabed material a year for 20 years in the South Taranaki Bight, supported by an economic impact assessment claiming large national benefits. Taranaki Offshore Partnership, which is developing an offshore wind farm in the same waters, asked us for an independent view.
What we did
We peer reviewed the applicant's economic assessment: its input-output method, multipliers, induced effects, labour market assumptions, and delivery risk. We then priced the opportunity cost of a forgone 1 GW offshore wind farm using published national studies, so the panel could compare the two uses of the same sea.
The result
Our evidence to the expert panel concluded that the claimed benefits had been materially overstated and that, once risk and opportunity cost were counted, the proposal was neither regionally nor nationally significant. The panel's draft decision proposed declining the application, citing our evidence, and the applicant withdrew it in February 2026. The work shows the other side of what we do: testing a project's claimed benefits as carefully as we build our own.